Enhancing Teaching Assistance Programs: Business Education Research Offers New Insights for Vocational Schools

oleh Tim SDGs FEB | Nov 11, 2025 | Uncategorized @id

By Agus Hermawan, Mohammad Arief, and Rachmad Hidayat
Faculty of Business Education – State University of Malang

Malang , Indonesia — A semester-long research project conducted by lecturers and students from the Faculty of Business Education has provided valuable insights into how Indonesia’s Teaching Assistant and Internship Program (TAP) can be improved to strengthen the preparation of future educators, particularly in vocational schools.

The study, titled “Business Education Students’ Perceptions, Challenges and Supports on Achieving Teaching Assistance Effectiveness in Indonesia,” examined how teaching interns in economic and business education experience their school placements — and what institutional and policy changes could enhance the effectiveness of the program.

A Semester in the Classroom: Bridging Theory and Practice

Conducted over one academic semester, the research involved 139 Business Education students participating in the national Teaching Assistant Program (TAP) under the Ministry of Education. The students were placed in vocational schools across Indonesia, where they served as teaching interns supporting classroom instruction, administrative duties, and learning innovation. Through surveys and open-ended feedback, the research explored how these interns balanced policy expectations, school realities, and pedagogical goals.

“Our aim was to understand the real teaching experiences of business education interns,” said Agus Hermawan, the lead researcher. “By identifying their challenges and supports, we can offer clear directions for improving teaching readiness and professional development.”

What Students and Supervisors Revealed

The study used a mixed-methods approach — combining quantitative analysis and qualitative interpretation — to highlight four interrelated pillars that determine the quality of internship programs:

  1. Structured pre-program coordination between universities and schools
  2. Adequacy of infrastructure and learning resources
  3. Reflective supervision from mentors and lecturers
  4. Context-driven training aligned with vocational education needs

The results were encouraging but also revealing.

  • 85% of students appreciated the coordination between universities and host schools.
  • However, 81.5% reported unequal school facilities that affected teaching outcomes.
  • Many interns also struggled with administrative tasks that limited their pedagogical focus.

Learning Through Experience

Grounded in Experiential Learning Theory, Social Cognitive Theory, and Andragogical Principles, the study connected practical experiences to theoretical insights.
“Teaching assistance programs are not just about classroom observation,” explained Mohammad Arief. “They are learning laboratories where students apply, reflect, and grow into professional educators.”

The research emphasized that the combination of guided reflection, supportive supervision, and context-based preparation can significantly improve student teachers’ competence and confidence.

Recommendations for Improvement

To make the program more effective and equitable, the researchers proposed several key recommendations:

  • Earlier disbursement of funds to ensure logistical readiness before placements
  • Simplified reporting and documentation to reduce administrative strain
  • Zoned school placements to minimize travel and ensure balanced access to resources
  • Blended pre-internship workshops, combining online modules with direct mentoring

“These recommendations are not just procedural,” noted Rachmad Hidayat. “They are essential to enhancing the quality and consistency of teaching assistance across vocational schools.”

Why This Matters for the Academic Community

  • The study’s findings hold significant value for students, lecturers, and researchers in Economic and Business Education.
    For students, the insights provide a clearer understanding of what to expect and how to prepare for internship experiences.
    For lecturers and supervisors, they highlight strategies to improve mentoring and field evaluation.
    And for researchers, the data open pathways for further studies on internship governance and pedagogical innovation.
  • Ultimately, the research concludes that effective governance and adequate resource provision jointly determine teaching competence — a message that resonates across Indonesia’s growing vocational education landscape.

Toward a Stronger Internship Framework

The Faculty of Business Education hopes these findings will guide universities and policymakers in refining the national teaching internship model. “Through continuous evaluation and collaboration,” said Hermawan, “we can ensure that every teaching assistant experience contributes meaningfully to the formation of competent, reflective, and innovative future educators.”

About the Study

This study was part of the faculty’s initiative to assess Teaching Assistant effectiveness in vocational schools under the Indonesian Ministry of Education’s experiential learning policy. The findings underscore the importance of integrating theory, practice, and support in teacher education.